MELTON & MOORABOOL
Home » News » MP slams double standards

MP slams double standards

A western Victoria MP has lashed state government imposed restrictions.

Member for the Western Victoria Region Bev McArthur said a number of restrictions in place – including those around firearms and fishing – were too city-centric.

“The ban on the sale of firearms and ammunition was clearly a method of appeasing the fears of inner-city Melbournians, who thought a pandemic might mean there would be armed criminals roaming the streets because they saw it on the television,” Ms McArthur

“It is integral that households obey the stay-at-home directive from the federal government, but the state government’s restrictions display serious double standards.

“To allow running around the suburban block, when you might pass several individuals on the route, but ban fishing, when you might not see a single other individual besides passing them in your car, makes no sense.”

Ms McArthur said there didn’t need to be specific exemptions for regional Victorians, but rather a rule of commonsense.

“Lower population density in the country means that recreational activities in the bush have a much lower risk of spreading the virus and while obviously abiding by social distancing rules.”

“The fines should be based around the social distancing measures in place, not the activities.

“If there are thirty people fishing on St Kilda pier, clearly that’s unacceptable. If there’s one bloke fishing alone on a lake in rural Victoria that the police happen to notice, there is no reason to hand out a fine.”

She warned that people will quickly tire of being told how to live.

“If public messaging is confusing, the rules are inconsistent and some sections of the community feel as if they are being unfairly targeted, like law-abiding shooters, then some will become increasingly unhappy and less compliant.”

“Our state government needs to beware of overreach when it comes to curtailing all individual freedoms and liberties. Locking people up in flats and houses will also have consequences.”

“We need to continue to listen to experts, use common sense, and governments need to stop using the crisis to take more control over individuals’ lives.”

Digital Editions


  • Obscene exposures in Melton

    Obscene exposures in Melton

    Police are appealing for information following a series of obscene exposures and linked sexual assault in Melton last week. Detectives have been told a woman…

More News

  • Moorabool welcomes new Aussies

    Moorabool welcomes new Aussies

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 323327 Moorabool’s Australia Day celebrations will bring together people from all around the world as 56 new citizens officially call Australia home. The new…

  • Cemetery on the way

    Cemetery on the way

    Victoria’s largest cemetery to be developed in over a century is taking shape at Harkness Memorial Park. The 128-hectare site is set to open in early 2027. The main works…

  • Australia day hours

    Australia day hours

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 260628 Council services and facility hours across Melton will change over the Australia Day public holiday on Monday 26 January. Council civic centres and…

  • Melton welcomes new citizens

    Melton welcomes new citizens

    Melton is gearing up for a memorable Australia Day this year, with 400 residents from more than 50 countries set to become Australian citizens at a special ceremony in Cobblebank.…

  • Lions run halted

    Lions run halted

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 512547 Melton was unable to keep the momentum going in the Victorian Sub-District Cricket Association east-west on Saturday. Facing Balwyn in a one-dayer, the…

  • Faces of the west

    Faces of the west

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 526797 Each week Star Weekly photographers are out and about capturing events and people across the west.

  • Community calendar

    Community calendar

    Community band The Greater Western Community Band meets Thursdays from 7.30-9.30pm. The rehearsal venue is the Bridge Road Community Centre, Strathtulloh (Melton South). The band is available for events. Brass,…

  • From the archives

    From the archives

    30 years ago 24 January 1996 Melton Shire’s police numbers will receive a significant boost when 18 officers are assigned to the new Caroline Springs station, due to open in…

  • Aintree SES open day

    Aintree SES open day

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 166112 Aintree’s SES unit is opening its doors to the public as it searches for new recruits to join the team. Recruitment is now…

  • Two arrested for stolen vehicles

    Two arrested for stolen vehicles

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 206998 A 17-year-old girl from the Melton area is among two teens arrested after police tracked an allegedly stolen Volkswagen Tiguan through the Creswick…